Auteur Topic: Examining btrfs, Linux’s perpetually half-finished filesystem  (gelezen 521 keer)

Offline m4v3r1ck

  • MVP
  • *
  • Bedankjes
  • -Gegeven: 3003
  • -Ontvangen: 318
  • Berichten: 2.629
  • $ sudo -i
Examining btrfs, Linux’s perpetually half-finished filesystem
« Gepost op: 25 september 2021, 20:45:45 »
Wat is de relevantie hiervan voor onze Synology NAS, nu en in de toekomst?

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/09/examining-btrfs-linuxs-perpetually-half-finished-filesystem/

TL;DR  ;)

Conclusions

Believe it or not, we've still only scratched the surface of btrfs problems. Similar problems and papercuts lurk in the way it manages snapshots, replication, compression, and more. Once we get through that, there's performance to talk about—which in many cases can be orders of magnitude slower than either ZFS or mdraid in reasonable, common real-world conditions and configurations.

We'll return to this analysis in the near future. In the meantime, if you're going to run btrfs in any configuration in which it manages multiple disks—as opposed to, eg., Synology and Netgear NAS devices, which crucially layer btrfs on top of traditional systems like LVM to avoid these pitfalls—please do so very carefully.
Commander: DS1821+ | DSM 7.2-64570 U3
SightWinder: DS1821+ | DSM 7.2.1-69057 U4 VMM
Wingman:     DS1812+ | DSM 6.2.4-25556 U7
UPS:             APC Back UPS BE850G2-GR (2x)
________________________________________________________________________________
Cheers! - ! I am an advocate of the "if it ain't broke, you didn't fix it enough" modus operandi !

Offline Briolet

  • Global Moderator
  • MVP
  • *
  • Bedankjes
  • -Gegeven: 180
  • -Ontvangen: 2668
  • Berichten: 16.550
Re: Examining btrfs, Linux’s perpetually half-finished filesystem
« Reactie #1 Gepost op: 25 september 2021, 21:31:37 »
Geen relevantie. Dat staat in de conclusie.

Citaat
as opposed to, eg., Synology and Netgear NAS devices

Zover ik begrepen heb, gebruikt Synology nog steeds EXT4, maar dan met een btrfs sausje eroverheen.
  • Mijn Synology: DS415+
  • HDD's: 3x 3TB in SHR
  • Extra's: DS212J, RT1900ac

Offline m4v3r1ck

  • MVP
  • *
  • Bedankjes
  • -Gegeven: 3003
  • -Ontvangen: 318
  • Berichten: 2.629
  • $ sudo -i
Re: Examining btrfs, Linux’s perpetually half-finished filesystem
« Reactie #2 Gepost op: 25 september 2021, 21:39:09 »
Mijn openingszin is niet goed geformuleerd, daarom de conclusie er maar gelijk bij geplakt! Vergeten de zin aan te passen…  (:
Commander: DS1821+ | DSM 7.2-64570 U3
SightWinder: DS1821+ | DSM 7.2.1-69057 U4 VMM
Wingman:     DS1812+ | DSM 6.2.4-25556 U7
UPS:             APC Back UPS BE850G2-GR (2x)
________________________________________________________________________________
Cheers! - ! I am an advocate of the "if it ain't broke, you didn't fix it enough" modus operandi !